Earlier this week, you studied two paintings of Mary and Jesus:
- Cimabue's Maesta of Santa Trinita (an example of a medieval painting)
- Raphael's Alba Madonna (an example of a Renaissance painting)
We will use these two paintings as our introduction to the Renaissance. We will discuss similarities and differences between the two paintings, and we will start to learn about the way that
art can help us understand people's ideas about religion.
-----------
Here are a few of your excellent observations from Monday's assignment:
Maesta of Santa Trinita, by Cimabue
Daniel and
Sebastian L.: Jesus and Mary are sitting on a beautifully carved golden throne. In the Bible story, weren't Mary and Joseph poor? And isn't Mary supposed to be humble?
Sebastian L., Jacob, and
Daniel: Mary looks so sad, and everyone looks solemn and serious (even
sour and
grumpy).
Why?
Alex A.: Jesus has a man face but a baby body!
Henry, Pete and
Grace W.: The main colors of the painting are gold, brown, and coppery red. Maybe the gold represents that God is divine, or maybe the gold is showing that Mary is a queen?
Ginny: The artist used a lot of gold, and I think he did that because gold is kind of the color of power and importance.
Sam: The majority of the colors are tan and brown, which makes it look like the painting was baked!
Kate R., Landon and
Charlie: Mary and Jesus are disproportionate to the angels and the men at the bottom. (1) It's almost like the artist is showing Mary as the mother of all the other people in the painting. (2) Since Baby Jesus is almost as big as the men at the bottom, this probably shows the power he has.
Hadley: Jesus has special
line designs on his halo, while the other people have circular designs.
Ellie, Grace E., Emily and
Jayden: All of the angels have the same face. They are all alike, without any individual character or personality.
Ella and
Dante: I think the people at the bottom are the prophets or priests who predicted Jesus's birth. I think that because they are holding scrolls, and they used to write the Bible in scrolls. I don't know the language that's used on the scrolls.

The Alba Madonna, by Raphael
Cort, Durland and
Grace E.: Mary is holding a book. Is it the
Bible? Did the real Mary know how to read?
Carson: Mary and Jesus are gazing at the other baby, instead of looking at you.
Hunter: The whole family is looking at the cross, so they probably know that the cross means something.Katie, Dante and Pete: Jesus is holding a skinny gold cross, but he is just a baby and I thought that’s how he died. So why is he holding it? Does Jesus already know that he's going to be crucified?
Carter K., Noah, Palmer and
Keegan: There are so many realistic details in this painting. The clothing looks so realistic (
the wrinkles are amazing!).
Ashton: In the first picture, Mary has more angels surrounding her giving her more of a regal look. And in the second picture, Mary at a first glance seems normal because you can’t see the halos.
Olivia T.: Jesus doesn't have any clothes on.
Caroline R.: It is hard to see but there is a tiny halo around baby Jesus’s head -- maybe because he is young and new to Christianity? (Ari noticed that the baby on the left also has a very faint halo!)
Aubreigh, Kate C. and
Davis W.: Mary is sitting on a tree stump.
Porter: Her "throne" is made of rocks or wood.
Ashton:
Right: she seems to be sitting on a throne of wood.
Oscar,
Carter K., Palmer and
Chaney: Mary and the children are sitting outdoors in this painting, with a farm, mountains, and beautiful fields in the background. It's a much more
natural painting.
Carter M., Stuart, Chapin, Keira, Hadley and
Davis O.: This painting is very colorful; plus, the colors in this painting are
bright,
vibrant, and
vivid. Mary's blue robe and pink shirt really stand out; her blue robe matches the blues of the sky and the flowers next to her feet. Her shoes remind me of the sandals known as Chacos!
Juliet: The colors in this painting make it seem more sweet and delicate, while in the other painting it looks a little more harsh and powerful.
Kate R.: The colors that the artist used most frequently in this painting are blue and brown. These colors allow Mary to seem like she is more human and not crazy high up.
Phoebe: The artist used the color blue frequently, maybe because blue symbolizes peace, being calm, and
trust.
Ellie, Charlie, Sam and
Aubreigh: This painting is an unusual shape. Why did Raphael choose to make this a circular painting?
Molly:
This painting looks like it's in a telescope, because there is a circle and it's zoomed in!Miller: In the background there are horses (they are very small but I zoomed in and they are clearer).
Sebastian C.: On Mary's left (over her shoulder), there are two people standing in the trees!
Great work by Emily, Axel, Charlie, Sebastian L., Miller, Kate R., Davis O., Keira and Porter, who identified the boy on the left as John the Baptist!